At $6,729, Monroe County’s average premium tops the list, while Sumter County is the state’s most affordable for property insurance with an average $1,438.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/baaca/baaca32a37de4a76f0a72a93cd5bae95b023d6b7" alt=""
At $6,729, Monroe County’s average premium tops the list, while Sumter County is the state’s most affordable for property insurance with an average $1,438.